Copyright 2011-2019. All Rights Reserved.
- RT @MrAndrewCotter: Some sports are slower. More about the strategy. https://t.co/JMBaGJ1tSd 6 months ago
- RT @R_Thaler: Brilliant piece by Michael Lewis. Needs to go viral so please RT bloomberg.com/opinion/articl… 6 months ago
- A #LeapYear puzzle welltemperedspreadsheet.wordpress.com/2012/01/27/puz… 7 months ago
- Join us at QWAFAFEW Denver on March 5th for our first-ever presentation on Environmental, Social and Governance (ES… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 8 months ago
- September in Paris
- Talk on Alternative Factor Investing
- Bond Talk on May 23
- New Paper on Bond Portfolio Dynamics
- Spam Followers
- The Invisible Run-Off
- My Letter to the Wall Street Journal
- Quarter the Cross: An Elegant Construction
- Quarter the Cross
- My FT Alphaville Commentary on Managing U.S. Treasury Debt
Top Posts & Pages
- Puzzle #2: Weighted Average LTV
- Fast Formulas #3: Pool Average Life with CPR Prepayments
- Financial Math Puzzles
- Puzzle #1: Mortgage Average Life
- Fast Formulas #1: Average Life of Mortgage (as Scheduled)
- Puzzle #5: A Royal Mystery
- Puzzle #8: James Bond
- Puzzle #11: A Pi Day Problem
- Good Fences Make Good Spreadsheets, Part 1
- Average Life Formula
- Benjamin T. Solomon
- Big Data
- Bond Math
- Bond Math Puzzle
- Bond Puzzle
- Brandeis University
- Brookings Institution
- Calendar Puzzle
- Callable Premium Bonds
- Carmen Reinhart
- Christmas Trees
- Closed Formula
- Cool Graphs
- Excel Tables
- Fast Formulas
- Federal Reserve
- Finance Math Puzzle
- Financial Math
- Floating Rate Debt
- Geometric Series
- Halton Sequence
- Interest Rate Risk
- Johann Sebastian Bach
- Ken Rogoff
- Loan Average Life
- Marc Faber
- Matt Henderson
- Mortgage-Backed Securities
- Municipal Bonds
- Municipal Finance Conference
- National Debt
- Precious Metals
- Public Debt
- Pure Math
- Puzzle #1
- Puzzle #2
- Puzzle #3
- Quasi-Geometric Series
- Representing Numbers
- Seeking Alpha
- Space Travel
- Spreadsheet Tips
- TED Talks
- The Bond Buyer
- Thomas Herndon
- Treasury Debt
- Treasury Floaters
- U.S. Treasury
- U.S. Treasury Debt
- UC Denver
- Weighted Average Life
- Weighted Average LTV
- Weighted Average Maturity
In a previous post, I described a paper on sovereign debt by Mattia Landoni (Cox School of Business – Southern Methodist University), Christopher Cameron (US Treasury), and me. Our paper gives a simple way to relate debt management policies and goals. We were very excited that it was accepted for the OECD‘s first Public Debt Management Conference in Paris last month. Mattia graciously consented to visit Paris and present for us (second or third row, left of center, facial hair, glasses, no tie). He reported that “the Dutch State Treasury Agency explained that they had already had the same intuition over 10 years ago”, and that our work was “the perfect theoretical underpinning” for their approach. Mattia was impressed with the high quality of the conference and the discussions. We are grateful for the feedback that will improve our paper.
QWAFAFEW* Denver meets September 12th with a discussion on alternative factor investing! Please RSVP now.
Event Details and Location:
We will meet at the Cactus Club in Denver, located at 1621 Blake St, starting at 5:30pm. Our format will allow ample time for networking both before and after the presentation.
The explosion in alternative data has been both a blessing and a curse to investment managers. Many more data sources have become available, thus expanding the opportunities for uncovering new sources of alpha. At the same time, the risk of wasting time on data issues or other dead ends has also increased. George Bonne from MSCI will join us to lead a discussion on the “alternative dataset” landscape and how investors are incorporating these tools, highlighting areas where research has indentified factors that add marginal explanatory power beyond traditional factors.
About Our Speaker
George Bonne, PhD, PRM joined MSCI in 2016 as Executive Director of Equity Factor Research, where he and his team work to create new and innovative factors to be used in MSCIs analytics and index products. Current projects involve exploring alternative and big data, exploring machine learning in factor construction and other areas, and investment crowding.
If you’re in Denver on May 23 and you’re interested in the bond market, join us for a QWAFAFEW* talk: Predicting the Supply of Long-Term Bonds. The talk will be based on a new paper by Mattia Landoni, Chris Cameron, and myself. RSVP here. I hope to see you there!
Mattia Landoni (SMU Cox School of Business) and I recently completed a paper on bond portfolio dynamics (now under review at an academic journal). We offer a new theory on the evolution of the maturity structures for rolling bond portfolios inspired by population mathematics, with new tools for evaluating and optimizing government borrowing strategies. The working paper is available at SSRN (free registration required), or you can contact either of us and we will gladly send you a copy.
A wave of spam followers has hit this blog, so I removed the “follow” feature. If you are sincerely interested in following this blog, please do so by contacting me. Thank you.
Today, the Alphaville section of the Financial Times published The invisible run-off, in which I discuss a new source of “quantitative tightening” that almost no one seems to have noticed. I estimate that $350 billion of private funds will be absorbed when the U.S. Treasury refinances its securities that are now in special accounts for state and local government bonds. The Treasuries are currently held in escrows to secure municipal bonds that have been “advance refunded.” An advance refunding is a complex refinancing technique for bonds that are months or years away from their first scheduled call date.
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act prohibits advance refundings going forward because they increase the supply of tax-exempt bonds (at least until the old bonds are called), thereby shaving the revenue to the Treasury.
According to the Joint Committee on Taxation, the end of advance refundings will save the federal government $17 billion over the next ten years:
Of course, that’s not much in comparison to the overall projected effect of tax reform:
Over the next few years, perhaps $350 billion in escrow Treasuries will mature. These will have to be refinanced without the help of new advance refundings. The run-off from escrows is not as large as the Fed’s expected balance sheet reduction (as much an obsession to the markets as a sizzling steak to a dog), but the escrow wind-down could match about a third of the Fed’s roughly $1 trillion planned disposal of Treasuries. The loss of escrow funding to the Treasury, and the additional supply to the market, could be prove significant.
The key to the $350 billion estimate for escrow securities was the S&P Municipal Bond Prerefunded/ETM Index. The index includes about $190 billion in bonds that have been escrowed to a call date (“ETC”) or to escrowed to maturity (“ETM”). I scaled up the prerefunded bonds by taking the ratio of the whole S&P municipal bond universe ($2.2 trillion) to the full reported size of the municipal market ($3.8 trillion).
I was interested to see that the average coupon of the prerefunded bonds in the index is 4.9%. This seems to confirm the prevalence of 5% coupons in recent years. These high coupons (their yield is now 1.6%) were among the most attractive candidates for refunding.
The escrow Treasuries generally have much lower coupons than the refunded bonds they support, so more than $1 in Treasuries are needed to cover the interest payments on each $1 of refunded bonds. This relationship implies that $350 billion could be a conservative estimate for Treasuries in advance refunding escrows. On the other hand, some of the escrows are so short that they are considered to be “current refundings” instead of advance refundings. Current refundings are still allowed, but their short shelf life has probably limited their impact on the index. To the extent that some bonds in the index correspond to current refundings, the $350 billion estimate could be on the high side. Another distortion would be if the prerefunded share of the S&P index universe does not match that of the whole market.
Addendum added January 21, 2018
The Wall Street Journal just published a letter of mine, Debt Bomb has Shorter Fuse Than Many Citizens Think (credit to them for the snappy title, and to my wife Corrina for invaluable editing). I respond to the Journal’s recent editorial Obama’s Debt Interest Bomb.
The editorial warned of a growing burden of interest payments on the national debt, due to rising interest rates and the anticipated drawdown of the Fed’s portfolio of Treasury securities. In my letter, I point out that the problem is exacerbated by two factors. First, the short maturity structure of the Treasury’s debt offers little protection against higher interest rates.
The second factor is the uneven composition of the securities held by the Fed. The Fed neutralizes the interest payments it receives by returning them back to the Treasury. Because the Fed tends to hold the Treasury’s higher-rate securities, the Treasury will sorely miss the Fed’s subsidy when it’s gone.
Last month, I presented an infinite pattern of nested crosses as a response to the #QuarterTheCross challenge on Twitter. The idea is to find interesting ways to shade one-quarter of the area of the cross built from five squares.Now David Butler, a math lecturer at the University of Adelaide, has found an elegant way to construct this pattern with the classic tools of compass and straightedge (I used some simple MATLAB code).
As the crosses get smaller, each new one must shrink by .
I asked David to explain his construction.
The segment marked “1” is of the “radius” from a corner of the outer cross to the center, so the construction generates an inner cross with the required radius, as long as the original radius.
A nice feature of this construction is that the compass is only used near the beginning. After that, the construction always provides a scaffold for the next inner cross.
Yesterday, I noticed that some of the math teachers I follow on Twitter were challenging their students, and themselves, with the #quarterthecross problem. The problem is simply to find interesting regions of a five-square cross that take up exactly one-quarter of its area. This looks like a great way to get kids to explore fractions and geometry.
A solution that occurred to me would be to use an infinity of nested crosses. If the area of the cross shrinks at each step by one-third, then the combined area of the colored regions converges to one-quarter of the large cross. This works because the alternating geometric series
converges to . Note that if the area shrinks by one-third, the width of the cross must scale down by the square root of 3. So every two steps the width shrinks by one-third, placing a little cross precisely inside the middle square of a larger cross.
My commentary Go Long, Mr Mnuchin has just been posted at FT Alphaville of the Financial Times.
I address whether the U.S. Treasury debt should be lengthened and whether it should sell 50-year or 100-year bonds. I think that “ultra-long” bonds are a good idea but that there won’t be enough demand for them to significantly reduce the Treasury’s interest rate risk. This should be accomplished by reshaping the whole distribution of maturities, which is currently very front-loaded. I also argue that the Treasury should update its measures of interest rate risk, and keep a close eye on how the Fed manages its Treasury portfolio.
Please check out the post and let me know what you think!
I am grateful to my wife Corrina for her essential suggestions and thoughtful editing through countless revisions.